Silverstein Politicizes Police

Late Wednesday evening, Ald. Silverstein announced that she and Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart “arranged a new partnership” with the 24th District CPD that will allow Cook County Police to patrol 50th Ward streets. She also announced that the 24th District police would send “saturation patrols” to do the same thing.

This simplistc over-reaction to recent gun violence along Devon Avenue is little more than Silverstein political grandstanding. It doesn’t speak well for Dart that he would send county police to the 50th Ward when they’ve never been sent to wards on the south and west sides where truly extreme violence is a daily occurrence. 

County Police will assist the 24th District for the next 30 days. Then they and the saturation patrols will depart. This is a classic case of preparing for situations that have already occurred. The waste of police resources is simply staggering.

Despite calls on social media for a community meeting to discuss the recent criminal activity along Devon, Silverstein  chose to ignore residents and politicize the police in order to advance her re-election efforts. 

The CAPS Coordinator for Beat 2411, Richard Concaildi, provided a fact-based, informative summary of the recent violence on social media platform nextdoor.com. Silverstein could not be bothered to do so. Instead, she once again shamelessly exploited tragedy for political gain.

In her email to residents, Silverstein couldn’t resist adding that Cook County Police have been involved “at (her) request” in other activities in the ward. Silverstein is referring to her bogus claims that she “organizes” multi-jurisdictional task forces to serve warrants and check on parolees.

At least Silverstein mentions 24th District Commander Roberto Nieves and gives him some indirect credit. Chicago Police Superintendent Eddie Johnson played no role in Silverstein’s version of events. She didn’t need to consult with Rahm Emanuel or Toni Preckwinkle either. And the last people she would talk with are her constituents. Instead, she and her little band of image consultants devised a self-serving and false narrative to impress voters.

If Silverstein really wants to be Police Superintendent, let her run for the job. Otherwise, she should allow police professionals to do their work without political interference.

The 50th Ward does not need the Cook County Police. The 50th Ward needs an alderman committed to the hard work of leadership, conomic development, and community empowerment.

Neither of her challengers is a perfect candidate. But each offers a vision for the ward that does not include turning it into a mini police state. Silverstein stokes fear because it translates into votes.

These are not the values of the 50th Ward.

 

 

A Week of Shootings

In the past 9 days there have been four shootings in the 50th Ward.

On February 7, at 5:30 p.m., a young man was shot in the leg at Devon and Oakley.

On February 14, at 1:30 p.m., a young man was shot in the leg at Devon and Leavitt

On February 15, at 11:30 p.m., two young men were shot in the 6500 block of North Albany. One of them, shot in the head, died. The other man, shot in the face, was hospitalized.

These shootings follow two other violent incidents:

On January 26, police were fired upon in an apartment on the 6400 block of North Kedzie. One officer’s bullet-proof vest was grazed by a bullet. The shooter, a man in his 30s, was described by his parents as mentally ill and was taken to the hospital for a mental evaluation by the police.

On February 5, police arrested a man who barricaded himself inside his home in the 6400 block of North Ridge. It was a domestic dispute; the woman involved alleged that the man had a weapon.

The alderman neither responded to nor even acknowledged any of these incidents until the double shooting on Friday. Those shootings led off her Newsletter, in which she declared that police patrols were increasing and that neither of the victims lived in that area.

Typical Silverstein response. During her campaign for re-election, she has repeatedly declared public safety her top priority. Are we supposed to feel safer because the two most recent victims don’t live “in that area”? Increased police patrols won’t prevent what has already happened.

During her re-election campaign, Silverstein has repeatedly referenced shootings in Oregon, California, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania as the reasons for her obsessive focus on police activity. Maybe she should pay attention to what’s occurring closer to home. Maybe she should work with the police and the community to identify potential problems in the ward. Maybe she can try to explain why shooters from outside the ward are coming here. Does West Ridge have a gang problem? A drug problem? A gun problem? Where is the police – community meeting?

All of these incidents happened on Devon or within a block or two of Devon. This is the heart of the 50th Ward’s immigrant community where families are struggling to survive in an environment they don’t understand. They are losing their children to gang activity because these young people have no jobs to go to and no safe place to hang out together.

What we are seeing here is the result of Silverstein’s refusal to engage in the hard work of economic and community development. There are no businesses hiring after-school help. There is no opportunity for kids to participate in after-school cultural activities, such as music and art programs. After 8 years in office, Silverstein has failed to build a single community center. There is little to no help available for at-risk youth in the 50th Ward.

Silverstein prefers directing the cleaning of sewers to the tough work of providing economic and cultural opportunities for the community’s children.

Remember that when you cast your vote for alderman.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Follies Truth Squad: Silverstein Campaign Mailer, Part III

From the day she took office in 2011, Debra Silverstein has presented herself as our very own crime-fighting alderman. She is particularly concerned with property crime, and calls public safety meetings every time there’s an outbreak of graffiti or a rash of stolen bikes. She enjoys being viewed as the law and order alderman. But is this image accurate? 

Let’s examine Silverstein’s claims about her influence and activism on issues of public safety as she describes them in her recent newsletter/campaign mailer. Most of her claims are pure malarkey.

We all want to be safe on the streets and in our homes, but heaven help us if public safety is under the direction of a part-time alderman rather than full-time, experienced, highly trained professional police officers. I think we are better served if politicians leave police work to those trained to do it. Silverstein was a CPA and has no background in law enforcement, so her claims that she “organizes” police activities or (her old favorite resurrected on her campaign website) “multi-jurisdictional task forces” are ludicrous.   Of course, as alderman she has an interest in the ward’s safety, and I’m sure the police keep her informed of crime rates and trends, but she is not directly involved in determining police strategy and shouldn’t claim otherwise.

She states that she was “…instrumental in organizing the following activities to assist in fighting crime,” and then assumes credit for decisions such as adding more police officers and introducing smart policing technology. These are decisions and actions taken by the commanders of the Chicago Police Department and do not require input from Silverstein.

To begin with, neither more cops nor improved technology were added to the 50th Ward as she states. They were added to the 17th and 24th Police Districts. This is an important distinction because both districts cover more than one ward.  Silverstein’s wording suggests that these developments are specific to the 50th Ward and result from her work as alderman. This is not so.

More importantly, police officials direct resources where they are needed. Statistically, West Ridge is one of the safest areas in the City; it, too, covers more than one ward. But Rogers Park, where the 24th District Police are headquartered, experiences more crime than West Ridge. Its activist alderman, Joe Moore,  organized the public safety meeting held after the murders of Douglass Watts and Eliyahu Moscowitz in Rogers Park. Police Supt. Eddie Johnson and a host of other police officials discussed the crimes and reassured frightened neighborhood residents.

To respond to fears  in the Jewish community that Mr. Moscowitz was targeted because he was Jewish, police officials also held a community meeting in the 50th Ward. But Silverstein did not organize this meeting nor did she “bring” them here. This was a police response to a stunned and grieving community.

What Silverstein did do in the weeks that followed was milk this tragedy for political advantage, appearing at two prayer services, outdoor police roll calls, and, as always, having her picture taken. She attended the funeral for Mr. Moscowitz, and announced with great fanfare that a reward had been offered, addressing neighborhood residents via a series of emails.  When the press moved on to other matters, Silverstein lost interest, too. But she has several times used photos of herself taken at the prayer services  in her newsletters and on her campaign website. Tacky.

Silverstein’s response to the death of Mr. Moscowitz was very different from her response to two homicides that occurred within three days on Devon Avenue in 2016. The first was a young man shot by an estranged girlfriend. The second was a 19-year-old gang member executed as he sat in a car in a parking lot outside a liquor store less than two blocks from Silverstein’s office. There were no community meetings to discuss public safety, no police officials to reassure frightened people, no alderman to “organize” a response. Instead, Silverstein dismissed both events with a single line in her weekly newsletter, describing the two murders as “some shootings.”  Where was her compassion and concern for public safety then?

Silverstein believes that outdoor police roll calls help curb crime. I’ve been unable to find any documented research that this is true. The rationale is that these roll calls enhance police transparency and help build solidarity with the community. That appears to be more PR spin than fact. What it does in the 50th Ward is provide yet another opportunity for an aldermanic photo-op, like the silly shot of Silverstein exchanging a salute with police officers that she’s published in her newsletter.

Devising, improving, or supervising policing strategies are activities  outside the scope of Silverstein’s responsibilities as alderman. Her claims of being actively involved in police work and fighting crime are baseless but play well with an audience distracted by photos of her with cops.

Public safety. would be vastly improved if she just did her job and let the police do theirs.

Tragedy and Grandstanding

There’s nothing like an alderman so crass that she exploits fear, grief, and mourning to help herself get re-elected.

The Jewish community is reeling from shock, grief, and fear over the murder of Eliyahu Moscowitz, one of two men murdered by an unknown killer in Rogers Park last month, and the synagogue killings in Pittsburgh. And Debra Silverstein both shares and exploits those emotions. She cannot do enough to comfort and protect the Jewish community:

  • Special bulletins were issued by her office providing updates on the hunt for Mr. Moscowitz’s killer.
  • The alderman attended his funeral.
  • A special “community safety meeting” was called on Oct. 4 so residents could hear top police brass discuss progress on the case and measures undertaken to ensure the safety of the Jewish community and its synagogues. [City officials stated that there were no overt threats. Nor is there any evidence that Mr. Moscowitz was targeted because he was Jewish.]
  • At the alderman’s request—or so she implies–police patrols were increased in the 50th Ward on the morning of the Pittsburgh shooting, with police visiting each synagogue and offering condolences and protection in addition to the police squads stationed outside the synagogues during the Sabbath.
  • The neighborhood was invited to an outdoor police roll call and prayer service for the eleven people killed at the Pittsburgh synagogue. (The roll call was canceled after the officers stood in formation for awhile because they had to get to work.)
  • The alderman’s newsletter featured four photos of the roll call/prayer service, two of which featured the alderman. .
  • The alderman has just announced another outdoor roll call, this one for Nov. 7 (today) on the 3600 block of Devon, and has invited residents to attend, adding that they will also have an opportunity to meet the new police commander of the 17th District.

Contrast all this with Silverstein’s actions in 2016, when two men were murdered in three days on Devon Avenue.

  • Silverstein dismissed the murders in her newsletter as “some shootings.” Both victims were men, one shot in a domestic dispute, the other executed gangland-style as he sat in a car outside a liquor store less than two blocks from Silverstein’s office
  • There were no bulletins on the hunt for the killers.
  • Silverstein did not attend the funerals.
  • There were no community safety meetings. No police brass were asked to address the community. No one—not the alderman, not the police—assured residents in the surrounding area that they were safe, or that extra measures were being taken to protect them. Yet we were scared, too.
  • The alderman did not call for or suggest increased police patrols in the area.
  • There were no outdoor police roll calls.
  • There were no photos of the alderman comforting frightened neighbors.

The lives of these two young men were no less valuable than that of Mr. Moscowitz or the Pittsburgh victims. Their life choices may have led them in very different directions, but they, too, were someone’s sons. They, too, had family and friends who mourn their loss. They, too, left a stunned and frightened community.

We all live in an increasingly unsafe world. While Jewish communities rightly and understandably have special concerns, having been targets for millennia, murder is a horror that terrifies every person and every community everywhere. One of the requirements for public servants is that they show compassion and understanding for every member of the community. It’s the art and the act of leadership. .

Silverstein is clearly exploiting the recent tragedies affecting the Jewish community for political gain. She has put her re-election first. Enough with the outdoor roll calls and photos of herself intruding on police business. This isn’t leadership.

Grandstanding is not the next best option. Taking photos at prayer services for later use in re-election materials is appalling.

Someone should tell Silverstein.

 

Police Strategic Deployment Center Coming to 24th District

The Chicago Sun-Times carried an excellent and informative article yesterday about the new Strategic Deployment Center coming to the 24th Police District, which includes West Ridge.

Reporter Fran Spielman outlines the Center’s objectives and briefly discusses its success in other police districts in Chicago. The 24th District will get high-definition surveillance cameras as part of the crime-fighting strategy. However, the cameras will not include the SpotShotter technology used in neighborhoods with hundreds of shootings. Cameras using SpotShotter respond to the sound of gunfire and zero in on that area.

According to Alderman Joe Moore of the 49th Ward, more information about the 24th District’s new capabilities will be available later today.

Read the Spielman story for more details.

https://chicago.suntimes.com/news/strategic-deployment-centers-added-six-more-district-rogers-park/